top of page

Do Students Think We Should Continue to Teach Standard English?

eechols4

Rebecca Disrud

University of Washington Tacoma


The question of to what extent universities should enforce standard English conventions, if at all, is a pressing one, but the voices of students most affected by decisions either to endorse standard language ideology or to withhold instruction about codes of power are often missing from the discussion. This presentation describes how I redesigned my university’s credit-bearing, quarter-long tutor training course as an inquiry-based investigation into the evidence on language learning, code-meshing, descriptive grammar, and linguistic racism. At the end of the quarter, most students advocated for both continued instruction in standard English and for wider acceptance of language diversity.



185 views7 comments

7 Comments


Randall Monty
Randall Monty
Apr 22, 2021

Great work! Some stakeholders will try to justify "standard English" in economic terms, a tautology that goes something like, "the systemic conditions that facilitate linguistic racism can't be racist because they're systemic." How might you respond to faculty and administrators who would push back against what you're arguing for?

Like
Rebecca A. Disrud
Rebecca A. Disrud
Apr 23, 2021
Replying to

Hi Randall, Well, that's a big question that probably warrants a longer conversation! I haven't encountered that perspective before, though I have definitely heard many versions of the idea that standard English is "just the way things are." If you're asking me how to convince someone that systemic racism is real or that they're using a logical fallacy, I'm afraid I don't have a better answer for you than those that are already in circulation!


However, here are a few thoughts. I think it's important to note that my students do want instruction about elements of standard English as well as increased acceptance for language diversity, so I'm not completely pushing back against those who argue for the importance of…

Like

ejc2228
Apr 22, 2021

Hi Rebecca,


Thank you for sharing your findings! I'm definitely going to consider incorporating some of your readings and findings in my own tutor class. I especially like your twitter thread assignment!


Erin

UW Seattle

Like
Rebecca A. Disrud
Rebecca A. Disrud
Apr 23, 2021
Replying to

Thanks, Erin! I appreciate your comment.

Like

eechols4
Apr 21, 2021

Great work, Rebecca! Thank you!

Like

awalkerstromdahl
Apr 19, 2021

Hi Rebeca,

Thank you so much for sharing your findings on this subject. It is one I am very much interested in and think about often in my classrooms. I am curious if you have students do work around their beliefs on this subject (at the beginning, middle, and/or end of the class) and the ways it informs or is informed by their identities.

Ali Walker Stromdahl

Pierce College

Like
Rebecca A. Disrud
Rebecca A. Disrud
Apr 20, 2021
Replying to

Hi Ali, Thanks for your question! We do reflect throughout the quarter on these questions in a few ways. Because the students work consistently in the same small groups throughout the quarter, they get to know each other well and their in-class discussions often include stories and reflections about their lived experiences. I also pose discussion questions for each reading that students respond to on Canvas. I usually don't ask directly about relationships between language and personal identity because some students don't necessarily want to openly discuss that with their classmates, but I offer the option to discuss either an example from their experience or an example from the reading, and many students do choose to share about themselves. I…

Like

© 2023 by The Green Conference. Proudly created with Wix.com. 

bottom of page